Saturday, July 15, 2006

Does competition stall acceptance?

Can competition of products, without collaboration, cause the whole product space to not become as widely accepted?  I was thinking about this as it applies to internet services.  For example, in the comment tracking space there is coComment, co.mments, myComments, and Commentful.  Each of these will track your comments across various sites, as well as let you view others comments on the posts that you are interested in.

For tracking your own comments, each of these work equally well, as you click a bookmarklet when you add a comment.  But if you want to view other's comments, they would have to use the same comment tracking service as you are.  Otherwise, you would have to look for comments on all of the sites.  I think that this would frustrate users so much that they wouldn't use any of the services.

One way to solve this would for each of these services to work together and share data.  In some ways this is what the IM services have started to do.  Now people on Yahoo's and MSN's IM networks can talk to each other. Prior to that you would have to log into each service to talk to your contacts

Technorati Tags: , , ,

1 comment:

  1. Paul,
    I agree with you.
    Fragmentation works against the network, and eventually dies because the network has more value than any one service.
    That's one lesson I brought with me when I designed co.mments. Great services are part of the network, they don't create walled gardens.
    co.mments acts just like a feed reader.
    It caches comments from the blog (all comments, not just from other users) so you can read them through a better interface.
    It's a better way to follow conversations, not moving the conversations to a different places.
    Give it a try.


Unlocking Raspberry Pi Potential: Navigating Network Booting Challenges for Enhanced Performance and Reliability

I've set up several Raspberry Pis around our house for various projects, but one recurring challenge is the potential for SD card failur...